Opinion » News

Nascent social media call to relight Castro Theatre sign gets attention

Assistant Editor

The Castro Theatre sign beamed as revelers celebrated Barack Obama's presidential victory November 4, 2008. Photo: Rick Gerharter
The Castro Theatre sign beamed as revelers celebrated Barack Obama's presidential victory November 4, 2008. Photo: Rick Gerharter  

For decades the iconic Castro Theatre sign has lit up the nights in the city's LGBTQ district, and wowed residents and visitors alike particularly on historically busy Halloween and election nights in the neighborhood.

Now, due to the pandemic, the lights are off — but a nascent call on social media is asking for them to be turned back on.

Harry Breaux, a gay man who is a longtime community fixture, posted a message to the Castro Theatre management to Facebook urging it turn the lights on. He said he has tried to contact the theater but has not heard a response.

The theater, which has been at 429 Castro Street since 1922 — replacing a nearby theater built in 1910 — did not respond to multiple requests for comment from the Bay Area Reporter.

"The large sign and the marquee on the theatre was the beacon that we saw and it gave the Eureka Valley its new moniker, The CASTRO," Breaux wrote on Facebook about his first time seeing the lights when he first came to the Castro neighborhood in the early 1970s. "It pointed to a place in this country where tolerance and acceptance was available and many came. The sign on your theatre has great power, visually and psychologically. It has become the 'Heart of the Castro' in many ways."

Breaux said that the theater sign gave people hope during the AIDS epidemic and an era of more rampant homophobia.

"Now we have COVID and the shelter-in-place orders we're all living under. For the first time in as long as I can remember the sign is dark and has been for too long. During the long summer days, it wasn't as noticeable as it is now," Breaux wrote. "My request, supported by many, would be to have the sign and the marquee become an active part of the community right now when it's needed. ... Please help us find a way to support you in relighting the 'Heart of the Castro.'"

David Cannon, who runs the Castro to Valencia Walking Around Facebook group, told the B.A.R. he too is supportive of the idea. He asked in a Facebook post "why couldn't the Castro CBD look into their budget to light up the symbol of gay San Francisco known throughout the world?" He was referring to the Castro/Upper Market Community Benefit District.

"Over 100 comments on Nextdoor," Cannon wrote. "It's taken off. Harry Breaux was the one who had the idea, and he contacted me about collaborating. Everyone is asking where do they donate and there is no one or nothing in charge. It's simply an idea."

Comments have ranged from support to questions about whether a group like the Castro CBD, which receives most of its revenue from property assessments, should foot the electric bill or other costs for a private business.

Breaux told the B.A.R. that he is cognizant that the closure of movie theaters due to the pandemic is hurting them financially — movie theaters were closed citywide until October 7 and even now can only operate at 25% capacity up to 100 patrons, while concessions stands have to remain shuttered, which has led to many theaters deciding to stay closed anyway — but he feels where there is a will, there should be a way.

Breaux works at Alex Fitness on Market Street and said that the theater sign being off has put a "dark pall" over the neighborhood as the days get shorter and the sun goes down earlier. That will especially be the case starting Sunday when daylight saving time ends.

"The psychological aspect of it got to me," he said. "The Castro just became a cultural district and many businesses are going through hard times; considering those two things, surely someone, somewhere, somehow can find out how to bring back light. It's a worldwide beacon: Castro and Market. I mean it was the leader of gay rights. A lot of people passed through there, a lot of people who aren't around anymore."

Breaux said he knows that Andrea Aiello, a lesbian who is the executive director of the Castro CBD, is aware of the request. But when the B.A.R. contacted Aiello asking if CBD funds could be used for the purposes of relighting the theater, she wrote, "I have not seen his request. I really don't know anything about this at all."

Breaux said he contacted the office of gay District 8 Supervisor Rafael Mandelman.

"They kind of let me know that it's not in their purview," Breaux said.

When contacted by the B.A.R. October 30 asking for his response, Mandelman said that the proposal is "interesting."

"I'll have to find out more," Mandelman said.

Breaux feels that the marquee can be used for more than the current message touting that the theater will return to full operations after COVID.

"You could use that marquee to put up all kinds of messages of hope and clarity," he said.

"It's not a silly reason," Breaux explained. "The whole neighborhood is suffering. The Castro has shelter-in-place but is not dead-in-place."

Help keep the Bay Area Reporter going in these tough times. To support local, independent, LGBTQ journalism, consider becoming a BAR member.

Comments on Facebook